Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe

This Florida shrimp pie recipe is savory, creamy, and packed with coastal flavor. Using frozen shrimp and a ready-made crust, it’s quick to prep but full of sunshine and spice. Perfect for laid-back dinners or beachy brunches, this Southern-inspired pie hits all the right notes comforting, bold, and beautifully simple.

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe That’s Creamy, Cheesy & Coastal-Inspired

Shrimp and sunshine? That’s Florida in a bite. This Florida shrimp pie recipe brings those coastal flavors straight to your kitchen no seafood shack required. Growing up, some of our favorite meals happened in beach cottages with creaky floors, warm breezes, and pies that weren’t always sweet. This savory shrimp pie became a ritual. It’s rich, just a little spicy, and blissfully easy.

We first made a version of this pie on a whim using what we had in the fridge and a half bag of frozen shrimp. We swapped out the usual milk or heavy cream for chive-and-onion spread, tossed in pepper jack for a kick, and slid the whole thing into a pre-baked shell. It came out golden, bubbling, and gone in one sitting.

That’s the beauty of this florida shrimp pie recipe: it’s not fussy. It doesn’t ask you to shell fresh seafood or fuss with pastry. It’s just five ingredients six if you count the sunshine you’ll feel when you smell it baking. And trust us, it disappears fast.

Our readers have loved savory spins on classics before, like our shrimp and sausage foil packet dinner and the chilled, citrusy apple almond shrimp salad. This pie fits right in simple, shareable, and totally satisfying.

There’s something deeply nostalgic about combining seafood and pie crust. It feels coastal, comforting, and still a little surprising. This recipe captures that feeling.Summer cookout, picnic, or a casual backyard dinner — fits right in.

Why This Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe Stands Out

Not Just Another Seafood Bake

Most shrimp pies lean toward the creamy casserole or quiche category. But this florida shrimp pie recipe walks a different line it’s lighter, spicier, and way more exciting on the plate. The pepper jack cheese brings warmth without overpowering the delicate shrimp, while the chive-and-onion spread skips the heaviness of cream or milk.

Advertisement

Every bite has texture. There’s a bit of crispness from the deep-dish crust, a satisfying richness from the eggs, and those sweet, briny notes from chopped shrimp. You don’t need anything fancy to make it sing, either. That’s the charm it tastes elevated but takes just five ingredients and one bowl.

Plus, it slices clean and reheats well, unlike some seafood casseroles that fall apart on day two.

Coastal Convenience Meets Flavor

This recipe isn’t just delicious it’s smart. You can use frozen, cooked shrimp straight from the freezer aisle. No peeling, no boiling, and no fishy smells in your kitchen. Just thaw and chop.

The same goes for the crust. You’ll use a ready-made deep-dish shell, so no need to roll, chill, or trim. Just pop it in the oven to blind bake, and it’s ready to fill.

Busy parents love it. Students can make it. Even your friend who’s “not a cook” will feel like a pro after making this once.

It’s just like our zesty lime shrimp avocado salad quick to prep, refreshing to eat, and always a win. And if you need dessert, follow this pie with a slice of our brownie refrigerator cake for a perfect meal flow.

Prepping ahead or saving leftovers -- stores and reheats well.

Ingredients for the Best Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe

What You’ll Need for This Coastal Favorite

This florida shrimp pie recipe keeps it beautifully simple. With only five ingredients, each one does some heavy lifting to bring bold, balanced flavor. You’ll find these items in just about any grocery store, and the prep takes minutes.

What You’ll Need for This Coastal Favorite

Ingredient	Details
Frozen Deep-Dish Pie Crust	1 crust from a 12 oz Pillsbury™ 2-pack; let thaw 10–20 minutes
Chive-and-Onion Cream Cheese	½ cup (from 8 oz container)
Eggs	4 large, preferably at room temperature
Cooked Medium Shrimp	12 oz frozen; thawed, drained, deveined, peeled, tails removed, chopped
Shredded Pepper Jack Cheese	½ cup (about 2 oz); freshly shredded if possible

These five ingredients bring together flavor, richness, and that classic seafood-southern comfort fusion you expect from a standout florida shrimp pie recipe.

Advertisement

Why These Ingredients Work Together

The chive-and-onion spread adds creaminess with built-in flavor, eliminating the need for spices or extra seasoning. It also blends smoothly into the eggs, creating a custardy texture that sets beautifully.

The shrimp is the star here. Medium shrimp offer bite without overpowering the pie. Make sure to chop them coarsely, so they stay distributed throughout each slice.

Pepper jack cheese melts smoothly and adds a gentle kick. If spice isn’t your thing, Monterey Jack works well too.

And of course, the deep-dish crust is the foundation. It holds up during blind baking, prevents sogginess, and delivers that satisfying flaky texture with every forkful.

These ingredients are simple, but the result is anything but basic. It’s similar in spirit to our honey mustard romaine salad unexpectedly bold, yet clean and fresh.

If you’re looking for dessert after this savory dish, you’ll love our high protein cheesecake jars sweet, chilled, and just as easy to prep.

Step-by-Step Instructions for the Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe

Bake the Crust Right

Start by preheating your oven to 375°F. Place a cookie sheet on the center rack while the oven heats up this helps evenly cook the bottom of the pie and prevents sogginess.

Take one frozen deep-dish crust out of its packaging and let it thaw for 10 to 20 minutes. Once pliable, use a fork to gently prick the bottom and sides. This prevents bubbling while blind baking.

Place the thawed crust on the preheated cookie sheet and bake it for 9 to 11 minutes, or until it’s very light golden brown. Remove and set aside while you prepare the filling.

Tip: Don’t skip this step. Pre-baking gives your shrimp pie structure and that craveable crisp base.

Mix and Fill with Care

While the crust bakes, grab a medium mixing bowl. Add ½ cup of chive-and-onion cream cheese spread and beat it until it’s smooth and creamy. Use a whisk or electric mixer either works.

Advertisement

Crack in 4 eggs, one at a time, and beat after each addition. Your mixture should be smooth and well blended. No lumps here!

Now stir in the coarsely chopped shrimp and ½ cup of shredded pepper jack cheese. Fold gently with a spatula until everything is evenly combined.

Pour the filling into your pre-baked crust, using a spoon or spatula to spread it evenly.

This step is like building flavor layers just like we do with our no-bake Easter cheesecake and other creamy favorites.

Bake Until Just Set

Return the filled pie to the cookie sheet and bake for 30 to 35 minutes, or until the center is set. You’ll know it’s done when the edges puff slightly and the middle doesn’t jiggle when tapped.

Let it cool for 15 minutes before slicing. This resting time is crucial it helps the custard finish setting and makes it easier to cut clean slices.

If you’re serving it alongside something sweet (and fast), we recommend our brownie in a mug for an instant dessert win.

Essential Tips for the Perfect Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe

Fresh vs. Frozen Shrimp: What’s Best?

The short answer? Frozen shrimp is more than fine and often better. Most “fresh” shrimp at the store is just thawed frozen shrimp anyway.

For this florida shrimp pie recipe, we recommend 12 oz of frozen, cooked, deveined, and peeled medium shrimp. Make sure they’re tail-off to save yourself the hassle. Thaw completely, then pat dry with paper towels. This helps eliminate excess moisture that can ruin the texture of your filling.

If you’re a fan of our apple almond shrimp salad, you already know how well frozen shrimp performs when treated right.

Pro Tip: You can thaw shrimp quickly by placing them in a colander under cold running water for 5–7 minutes.

Say Goodbye to Soggy Crust

One of the most common problems with savory pies? A soft or soggy bottom. But this pie avoids that fate with a few simple tricks:

Advertisement

• Blind bake your crust for 9–11 minutes before adding the filling. This gives it a head start.
• Use a preheated cookie sheet to boost bottom heat during baking.
• Drain and dry your shrimp to avoid adding water to the filling.
• Let the pie cool for 15 minutes post-bake this helps the crust stay crisp.

These techniques are why our readers say this pie reminds them of a dish from a seaside café minus the travel.

Crust success is key for any bake, and just like we do in our cajun honey butter sauce recipe, small steps make a big difference in the final result.

Perfect Pairings, Creative Variations, and Storage Tips

What to Serve with Shrimp Pie

This florida shrimp pie recipe works for brunches, light dinners, or casual backyard get-togethers. It’s flavorful but not heavy, so pair it with sides that keep things bright.

Recommended pairings:

• A chilled citrusy drink or white wine spritzer
• Crisp green salad with zesty vinaigrette
• Something with a tropical note, like our cucumber and pineapple salad

Want to end on a sweet bite? Keep things no-bake and simple with date brownie balls a rich, chilled treat that pairs perfectly after seafood.

Smart Variations & Easy Swaps

Want to change things up? This recipe is flexible:

• Make it spicier: Swap in jalapeño jack cheese or add a few red pepper flakes.
• Add herbs: Fresh dill or parsley stirred into the filling boosts freshness.
• Mini version: Use muffin tins and mini crusts for party-ready shrimp pie bites.
• Dairy-free option: Use a vegan cream cheese and non-dairy cheese to make it lactose-friendly.

These swaps make the florida shrimp pie recipe work year-round, from holiday brunches to summer potlucks.

Storing Leftovers (If You Have Any)

This pie stores beautifully:

• Refrigerate leftovers in an airtight container for up to 3 days.
• Reheat in a 325°F oven for 10–15 minutes, or until warmed through.
• Avoid microwaving, which can make the crust soft.

It also tastes great cold yes, really! Just like a quiche, it’s delicious straight from the fridge the next day.

FAQs About the Florida Shrimp Pie Recipe

Conclusion

This florida shrimp pie recipe is a beach-inspired twist on classic comfort. It’s rich, savory, and packed with flavor, but still easy enough for a weeknight dinner. Using frozen shrimp and a store-bought crust, it keeps prep simple while delivering bold coastal flavor in every bite.

We grew up loving recipes like this low-stress, shareable, and always satisfying.Hosting or feeding a crowd — this one always earns its place.

It’s already a favorite alongside our shrimp roll with noodles and our other seafood-forward meals. And with just five ingredients, it’s one of the easiest impressive dishes you’ll ever make.

For more like this, follow us on Facebook or check out our Pinterest boards we’re always sharing new chilled pies, no-bake favorites, and cozy meals that bring people together.